Hey there!
Throughout the course of this week’s blog post I hope to present an informative interpretation of urban life in early 20th Century Boston, Massachusetts. Photography is intrinsic to our understanding of historical geography. Surveying the city in the early days of photography produced images used for educational or decorative purposes (Dennis 55). To the keen geographer in modernity however, they provide us with a record which we can analyse and interpret.
I will specifically be focusing on the idea of the spectacle and how spaces were provided for this using Franklin Park Zoo and Fenway Park as examples. Crowd engagement with celebrity has also proved to be a powerful political, cultural, economic and social tool and I will use Amelia Earhart and Babe Ruth to show this.
![Compiled Map Points](https://drawingfromthearchives.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/compiled-map-points.png?w=300&h=192)
Map 1.1: A quick illustration I mapped out using Google Earth to show where Images 1.2, 1.3 and 1.4 were taken. I have also roughly outlined Greater Boston.
You can click here for further online materials.
New York’s World Fair in 1935 opened with the slogan ”Dawn of a New Day” and encouraged visitors to embrace ”the world of tomorrow”. Exhibitions such as this were commonplace in the 19th and 20th centuries (starting in London’s Hyde Park) and these could be considered the beginnings of the spectacle on a large scale in the everyday urban environment.
Katie O’Sullivan | 112362596
Boston. (Arthur Griffin c.1935-55)
![AG1](https://drawingfromthearchives.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/ag1.jpg?w=800&h=637)
Image 1.1: Housed in Griffin Museum of Photography. Series: Boston Winter A. Filed under: Gelatin Silver Prints (8 x 10 in.) This aerial shot gives a good impression of Boston at this time. Faneuil Hall is centered (the building extends past the dome), giving due importance to the longtime meeting hall and marketplace ( est. 1742)
Brown bear takes a bath at Franklin Park Zoo. (Leslie Jones c. 1917-34)
![LJ4](https://drawingfromthearchives.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/lj4.jpg?w=300&h=232)
Image 1.2: Housed in the Boston Public Library. Series: Animals: Franklin Park Zoo. Filed under: Glass negatives (4 x 5 in.) This is a terrific image showing how animals forego their wild instinctive nature in favour of a passive human one when in captivity. It is also an interesting take on the idea of surveillance and who is really watching who, as the bear gazes directly out at us.
A zoo is at once, both a form of containment and display, inviting spectators to wander a 72-acre site, no matter the season. By putting wild animals in enclosures humankind has essentially reshaped nature (see Image 1.2). Even today, the zoo as a form of entertainment has not lost its popularity. It is easy to imagine how intimidating and exciting it was for children and adults to be so near to exotic animals they may never have otherwise encountered in 1912 when the Zoo opened. Zoos were also educational, teaching the general public about the geographical origins of the animals and their habitats, creating a more knowledgeable society.
Amelia Earhart at East Boston Airport in Ford Trimotor (Leslie Jones c. July 1920**)
![LJ3](https://drawingfromthearchives.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/lj3.jpg?w=300&h=233)
Image 1.3: Housed in the Boston Public Library. Series: Aviation: Boardman, Earhart & Grayson. Filed under: Glass negatives (4 x 5 in.) Before the aeroplane became a common mode of transport across the globe, one can only imagine the ‘wow’ factor at seeing someone fly; fast and high. It should be noted that there is a relatively heavy security presence around the crowd and a group of Native Americans at the top left; showing how Amelia was held in high esteem by a diverse range of people; men and women alike.
I came across countless photos of new technology and transport methods in the archives. However, I chose this particular one (see Image 1.3) as it demonstrates the celebrity combined with air transport. It is ironic that Jervis states ‘such machines [aeroplanes were] characteristically coded as masculine’ (1998, p. 213). Following on from this, we discussed how the role of women has changed over the centuries in lectures this week. This makes Amelia Earhart all the more special as she too became an icon, a female aviator enshrouded in success and mystery, disappearing 10 years after this visit to the grounds that later became Logan Airport.
Babe Ruth autographing at Fenway. (Leslie Jones c. 1934)
![LJ2](https://drawingfromthearchives.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/lj2.jpg?w=300&h=239)
Image 1.4: Housed in the Boston Public Library. Series: Baseball. Filed under: Glass negatives (4 x 5 in.) As a fan of rugby myself, I can relate to the youths in this image who yearn for a souvenir that can last a lifetime. This relationship is intrinsic as an autograph on a ball or jersey can be handed down in family history with the accompanying story ”I remember when I met Babe Ruth after that spectacular game …” as well as being of sentimental or even economic value.
Without the infrastructure of a park or stadium in which to practice and play competitively, baseball may never have taken off as a national sport. Fenway Park is iconic and the oldest Major League Baseball (MLB) park still in use (see Image 1.4). 1903 brought with it the first world series in the MLB as the Boston Americans (renamed the Red Sox in 1907) beat the Pittsburgh Pirates. Their early successes generated a large fan-base. It’s interesting to note that the fans Babe Ruth is attending to in the image are male. This shows the gender division in sports at the time.
State House fireworks. (Leslie Jones c. 4th July 1932)
![LJ 1](https://drawingfromthearchives.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/lj-1.jpg?w=800&h=622)
Image 1.5: Housed in the Boston Public Library. Series: Boston: Public Buildings. Filed under: Glass negatives (4 x 5 in.) This image is the very pinnacle of how most people would regard ‘the spectacle’; a fireworks show. However, there are politics of prestige and power involved in the organisation of such displays. This one for instance is held near the State House.
Jervis defines the spectacle as ‘an extravagant visual entertainment… [which] dramatizes and projects the passivity of experience, its dependence on canons of representation through which its meaning is shaped and defined’ (1998, p. 344).
To conclude, the growth of celebrity and success in sport kept the public in good spirits. Meanwhile an increase in outdoor family activities, celebrating Independence Day and trips to the Zoo helped reduce potential dissention. These public events, whereby people were regulated through spectating, became a kind of safety valve, a common conclusion among political historians. The diverse range of spectacles pictured above, acted as an underhanded method of regulating Bostonians and will last infinitely through the medium of photography.
That’s all for this week,
Katie O.
** The archival record date for Image 1.3 is incorrect as this was before Amelia became well known and admired, it is more likely to have been c. 1927-28
Bibliography.
See History | Sports and Leisure at <http://www.cityofboston.gov/visitors/about/trivia.asp>
Dennis, R 2008, Cities in modernity, Cambridge University Press, UK.
Jervis, J 1998, Exploring the Modern, Blackwell Publishing, UK.